Alex Carey's brilliant unbeaten Sheffield Shield century for South Australia on Tuesday was a welcome exception ahead of the India series after three days where Konstas and several other candidates flubbed their auditions for the Test batting vacancy.
And Smith might be revisiting his plan to miss the next Shield game, courtesy of an lbw dismissal at the MCG that had him fuming.
Steve Smith was furious after making a duck for NSW in the second innings against Victoria. (Morgan Hancock/AAP PHOTOS)
As the bowlers continued to dominate on day three of the Shield match at the MCG, Konstas had backed up his two in the first innings with a watchful knock.
Victorian captain Peter Handscomb dropped him in the slips on 23 off Test understudy Scott Boland, but otherwise the 19-year-old looked settled.
But the delivery after hitting a boundary off Todd Murphy, Konstas had a teenager's rush of blood.
He went down the track to the offspinner and top-edged to Campbell Kellaway, who took an excellent diving catch at point for 43.
Victoria's Campbell Kellaway took a fine catch at point to dismiss NSW teenager Sam Konstas. (James Ross/AAP PHOTOS)
After his two Shield tons against SA, Konstas needed another big score at the MCG to confirm he's a selection bolter for the first Test, especially after chief selector George Bailey had already intimated Cameron Bancroft and Marcus Harris were the front-runners for the vacancy.
Instead, Konstas will be left to regroup ahead of the upcoming Shield clash against Queensland - NSW's last game before players go into camp for the five-Test series against India.
Meanwhile, Smith vehemently shook his head in frustration after he left a Scott Boland delivery that swung in late and clipped his pad.
Given how well Boland was bowling, it was a risky decision that sent Smith back to the rooms for a fourth-ball duck.
Speaking after Tuesday's play, Smith had said he'd probably not play in their next Shield game.
The home game from November 1 against Queensland clashes with the one-day series against Pakistan.
"I will see how the second innings goes and talk to the powers that be and see what they think is best," Smith had said.
Test quick Mitchell Starc took 6-81 in Victoria's second innings as the home side set a victory target of 383. NSW were 6-185 at stumps, chasing another 198 runs for an unlikely victory on day four.
South Australia's Alex Carey hit a brilliant unbeaten ton in the Shield clash against Queensland. (Jono Searle/AAP PHOTOS)
Also on Tuesday, Carey (123 not out) continued his strong pre-Test form with an unbeaten century against Queensland at Allan Border Field.
The wicketkeeper boasts two tons and another score of 90 from four knocks for SA so far this summer, averaging 122 with the bat ahead of India.
Carey's form will be a welcome boost for an Australian side missing the injured Cameron Green and was on show with three back-to-back boundaries off Mark Steketee that led the wicketkeeper to triple figures.